As a fan of Snoopy comics and old animated movies, my initial reaction to this news was also “eww”. But to be honest, this 3D Snoopy doesn’t look all that bad. Well, it’s true we can now see Snoopy’s fur and – oh, good grief – Charlie Brown’s teeth! That’s a lot of unoriginal details compared to the comics. But if we look around at any other 3D animation we will notice the modeling of this movie is so simplistic. So it really depends on with what we compare it to. Going 3D inevitably brings texture, shading into the business. Apparently the movie makers don’t lack the technology to make it much more realistic (like what Disney did with the ice and the snow in Frozen?) But they choose a minimal setting, and perhaps even a bit too plain. That brings me into thinking that they have made an effort to try to balance between natural looking in 3D and the original style of simplicity. One doesn’t simply say something is inappropriate just because he believes it should just be the way he thinks it ought to be.
Since some protestors brought Tintin into the conversation, I will take it and I think it illustrates quite the opposite point. I first get to know about Tintin from none other but the 3D movie. I thoroughly enjoyed the movie. The animation quality only adds to its brilliance. (Uncanny valley? Just another typical syndrome of narrow-mindedness.) Exactly because of the movie, I got interested and moved on to read the original comic. At first sight I was amused by the portrait of Tintin. I thought, two dots for his eyes? But pretty soon I loved the comics no less than I do with the movie. So why can’t I be more open-minded towards the 3D Snoopy?
We see Snoopy everywhere, on pencil boxes, on T shirts. But how many know what kind of character Snoopy is? The point is to have more people discover the greatness inside the beagle. Some of them might, like myself in the case of Tintin, go to dig for the original comics. And maybe they will appreciate the comics better, or not. What matters is Snoopy continues to bring joy to the world, and his spirit continues to kindle our hearts.
Now that well reminds me of BT. His late effort has been devoted to making “entry level” EDM (I just meant dance-floor inspired). I remember him saying
…as people get into the dance music their tastes change and refine and then listening to something like what I do or Boards of Canada or Au5 appeals to them.
(Hey hey, I’m a living example here again!) So if he wants to make something to entertain his target for a while I’m all fine (though I don’t listen to them.) And this is analogous to what I’m trying to say here regarding the new 3D Snoopy movie. I might still not be so much a fan for the visuals. But judging from the trailer, which has already presented some of the very essence of the peanuts gang. I gladly look forward to seeing it. I hope it still conveys the warmth, loveliness and naughtiness, which could definitely be done.